Now the dust has settled on World of Warcraft Forever, all the big mechanical questions we might have had about how the grand reimagining of Blizzard’s MMORPG would work have largely been answered. That gives us space to discuss some of the juicier aspects, such as lore – although such topics might actually give us even more clues about what lies ahead. Senior Game Designer Josh Greenfield and Lore Historian Lead Sean Copeland are joined by Josh Corbett of Countdown to Classic, and WoW streamers ‘PlatinumWoW’ and ‘Nobbel87,’ to discuss Forever’s world, characters, and story.
Before we dive into all of that, Greenfield touches on some of the recent changes to World of Warcraft Forever’s PvP-side character creation. “We’ve kind of tightened it up a little bit, and unfortunately that means if you haven’t made a Horde character, you’re probably going to want to start making other arrangements at this point.” At 55% Horde to 45% Alliance, the split has grown beyond the 10% gap Blizzard is comfortable with, so it’s enforcing restrictions to maintain faction balance.
“That’s one of the most important things on a PvP server and we’re super-duper dedicated to making sure we maintain that balance,” Greenfield continues. He notes that despite rumors of players flooding the servers with level-one characters or trial accounts to skew the numbers, “That isn’t really how the system works.” He explains, “You can make a million level-one characters and it’s not really going to impact anything, how we balance the ruleset level is we look at characters over a certain amount of time actually playing the game.”

Moving into the lore side of the chat, Copeland gives us his background, describing himself as “The park ranger of Warcraft – I know it like the back of my hands, and my job is to make the decades of lore weightless for Josh, for anybody working on Forever.” With this breakaway moment from the modern game, he says there was “a very conscious decision all the way up the chain that it should be a branching continuity.” He compares it to how Hearthstone was built on the same fundamentals, then grew into its own spin on Warcraft.
“There was a period of time where we were just going to put it in the main continuity, and we were ‘just going to do a really good job of not breaking anything on modern WoW,'” Greenfield adds. “I think [Warcraft’s Executive Creative Director] Chris Metzen and I ran into each other at food trucks on a Thursday,” he recalls, “and we just got to talking and we’re like, ‘You know what? We need to split this thing, man, we’re going to create landmines for each other, we’re going to cause all sorts of issues.”
Ripping that band-aid off was “liberating for the Forever team,” and allows the newest WoW incarnation to “exist on its own terms” rather than simply feeling like it’s filling in the gaps for a story that’s much further down the line in retail. Greenfield reveals that working on Season of Discovery for WoW Classic “really helped, because we’d already kind of started to think about Forever when we were working on that.” He notes that trying to fit things into existing lore was “really difficult,” and that SoD did end up with a handful of possible contradictions.

Discussing aspects of WoW that he’s eager to tackle in Forever, Greenfield mentions Vol’jin and Ashbringer, before hinting, “Scarlet Enclave will return, Ashbringer will return at some point. It might be a while, but that’s going to come back.” For a deeper cut, he offers up Pained, Jaina’s loyal bodyguard. She “basically does nothing in all of vanilla,” he remarks, but he “really, really, really” wants to expand on her. “She just has a badass name, and just has aura, and I just want to do something cool with her – what was she doing on a weekend in 2004?”
Copeland is similarly smitten with Ashbringer. “It has a very special palace in my heart because I was there when the graphic novel was being created,” he recalls. “Tyrion being alone in the whole Taelan Fordring quest in Classic, that resonates with me because he’s about to go do – what we know – amazing things. But if we had the runway to be like, ‘What is Tyrion up to? He had to give up his entire life. He was expelled from the Silver Hand, he’s living here, but he’s still close to his son, who by the way is a Scarlet Crusader.” He even touches on the Argent Dawn and Scarlet Crusade rift, and the idea of exploring “more stories at the ground level” in the midst of that split. “Families were ripped apart in this.”
However the story branches from the original WoW narrative, building on those foundations means there still won’t be a big quest marker “that says ‘Go here, this is the Main Campaign. Do this.'” It’s more about how all of the myriad smaller stories gradually weave together. “You may be doing quests right now in WoW Forever that are part of a larger meta narrative,” Greenfield hints, “and that’s how early WoW was, right?” Expect deviations from the path, “but we hope it’s something that’s a surprise and a delight, and not a headscratcher.”

Players are already building their big conspiracy theories and speculations about where Forever might lead. “That’s a Tuesday night for me and I want to give a huge shout-out to them,” Copeland grins, “they’re doing amazing things.” Ideas such as early quests hinting towards later parts of WoW could be on the table if they “sound cool,” but Copeland is more enthused about untouched areas of the map. “Creative things like, ‘Hey, have you thought about going to this place? This region’s untapped, why can’t we go there?'”
Greenfield says the team is eager to take underutilized characters and locations and build those out. “There are also a lot of characters that are dead in modern WoW that are like, ‘Man, that’s some really fertile ground.’ I’m not necessarily interested in retconning their death in WoW Forever, but giving them something to do,” he explains, returning to his earlier question: “What was this character doing on a weekend in 2004? I love exploring stuff like that. The team really loves exploring stuff like that.”
In terms of major antagonists, the team is trying to steer clear of “having a central villain that is the only thing that matters for years and years,” Greenfield notes. “There have always been big, scary villains in World of Warcraft,” and he believes big bullet-point baddies such as Ragnaros certainly have their place. “For example, we haven’t gotten to Molten Core yet, but at some point we will, and that’s an anchor point.” From there, he suggests future such anchors could land on “Blackwing Lair, then Ahn’Qiraj, and so on and so forth.”

“We want to focus on those villains that made those places memorable, but also just expand sort of laterally on that and create new villains, or explore existing villains along the way. That’s not to say there won’t ever be an overarching villain,” Greenfield remarks. “We’ve got some pretty fun ideas for that if we do want to get there, but it’s mostly that we want the story to be very organic and natural, and we don’t really want to say, ‘This is the bad guy. This is the thing to care about for the next two years. Only care about that.’ There’s nothing wrong with that, by the way, that’s totally an okay approach, but that’s not the kind of game this is.”
Not all the new pieces will land at max level. “We definitely want to seed stories in lower-level content,” Greenfield says. He points out there are already some earlier quests in Forever that begin to uncover narrative threads leading into new high-level content. “I will occasionally go onto Wowhead to read comments on quests and see if people have put it together yet.” He suggests the idea of creating “a level-30 zone that is the companion to an endgame zone,” and would be filled with various chains that give you a consistent throughline.
There’s a sense of cheer around WoW Forever’s launch, but Greenfield reminds us that, tonally, “Original WoW has some pretty dark stuff – the Legend of Stalvan, I replayed that for the first time in several years last year, and I was like, ‘Man, this is so dark. This is serious business.'” He says Blizzard “made a conscious choice” for WoW Forever” to maintain “I don’t want to say ‘darkness,’ but ‘seriousness.'”

“That doesn’t mean there’s not going to be levity in the game. There’s funny stuff, there’s heartwarming stuff. There is a gamut of different emotions we want you to feel when playing this game. But we are definitely trying very hard to keep it in that original WoW sort of tone.” Greenfield says Forever’s leadership playtests to determine if things feel too “silly” or “off-tone” and need reining in to feel consistent. “That’s something we’re trying really hard to do.”
Copeland hypothesizes for a moment about some other aspects he’d love to touch on. “I’ve really wanted to dig into the War of the Satyr,” he says, “Or the War of the Spider – these are things that we can’t talk about in lore because they’re a different part of a different era. But there have got to be places in the world that had major conflicts. Or where Alpha Prime actually got the Worgen form in the first place. These areas that exist – I don’t want it to just live in a comic, I don’t want it to live in a story. I want it to be something we can all go, ‘Here. This is where it happened. This is important.'”
Despite all this work on the lore and narrative, Greenfield offers an important caveat: “In original WoW, you could completely ignore the story, and that’s actually okay.” By following similar storytelling methods to those early days, Forever should similarly let you choose how much personal investment you have in that side of the MMO. “It’s okay if you want to focus on the gameplay, if you want to focus on getting sweet loot and killing raid bosses and stuff,” he reassures us.
“We’re not tripping over ourselves to add things like cutscenes or really heavily scripted sequences,” Greenfield continues, although he does note that a few exceptions might be made for major “lore-impactful moments” such as the Onyxia questline. “We certainly don’t want to get into a situation where your character is central to the events,” he emphasizes. “You’re still a murder-hobo, you’re still just a hero, not the hero. That’s what we want to focus on, is keeping it about the world more than your character or any one hero.” Copeland chimes in, “And the people that stepped up – that’s the best part of this era.”
With the introduction of new race/class combos in Forever, PlatinumWoW brings up a previous Season of Discovery overview video that teased combinations we’ve not yet seen. Does that mean they’re on the table? “I hate to be boring, but no,” Greenfield answers with a smile. “The team that made it, I think they just thought it looked cool. But hey, you know, never say never – I’d love to see more races get Shamans, for example. I’d love to see more Horde races get Priests.”
I’ll leave things there for today, but be sure to dig through the video if you’re curious to hear more tidbits about the creation of the new Skyborne race, or the Riverglades region, along with some bonus thoughts on Undead Paladins. If World of Warcraft Forever lives up to its name, we could be looking at something completely fresh and unique in just a few years, and that’s probably the most exciting part of all.

